Jane Eyre Masculinity

1665 Words7 Pages
American writer Susan Sontag declares that “What is most beautiful in virile men is something feminine; what is most beautiful in feminine women is something masculine.” In Victorian society, there is a dichotomy of feminine and masculine traits that separate the genders and the acceptance of other gender’s traits is what ultimately leads to happiness in relationships. In Persuasion by Jane Austen, men are the ones who end up accepting women by accepting that femininity is not inherently bad through the female characters and, while in Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte the women who are successful are the women who embody more masculine traits throughout the novel. Jane Austen and Charlotte Bronte each use small style choices to relay the masculinity…show more content…
The protagonist, Jane Eyre, would be a foil to Anne Elliot if they were characters in the same novel. Where Anne fades into the woodwork, Jane makes her opinions loud and clear. Jane is described as a “mad cat” by a household servant when Jane stands up for herself against the cruelness of her cousin John (Bronte 8). While achieving the same effects as Austen, Bronte creates a character who has a backbone which is extremely uncommon for female characters in the Victorian time period. Jane Eyre is a strong female character to the point that “only starvation is enough to force her into the salutary humiliation of begging” which is untrue of many female characters in literature (Dessner 77). During the Victorian time period, “women like Jane are treated unequally in every field” so that fact that “she wouldn’t give up her independence and self-respect” and gives Jane a feministic approach to life (Gao 927, Gao 929). Bronte’s long and complex sentences also add to the complex nature of Jane Eyre herself (Page ). Jane is a complex character that often thinks in round about ways. The complex sentences also lend themselves to the idea that men were the complex and civilized beings where as women, as seen in the short and rushed sentences in Jane Austen’s Persuasion, were seen as to have ability for social and complex thought. The differences in these characters boil down to the differences of masculinity…show more content…
Persuasion is the key attribute to Anne that creates a feminine air around her that makes her character to believable and more of a female role model than a classic naïve girl. “Anne is withdrawn, taciturn, and often solitary, so that her most powerful feelings general go unexpressed” but it is in these classic Victorian feminine traits that keep her aloft in her family. Like females in society, “her word had no weight; her convenience was always to give way;-she was only Anne” which creates in Anne the epitome of feminine traits (Austen 1146). The traits that make her such an effeminate character are the ones that ultimately give her the ‘happy ending’ that she craves from the beginning. When Anne is speaking or doing something she is described as quiet, “Anne quietly tried to convince her” or “Anne avoided a direct reply” (Austen 1205). Anne is “faded and thin” which is attributed to her feminine side that ultimately makes her attractive to both the reader and to Captain Wentworth (Page 48). By adding these small adjectives, Jane Austen creates a demure character that seems to never speak much louder than a whisper. Jane Austen uses the femininity of her main heroine to create a positive effect towards the way women already are and goes to great lengths to show that the feminine persuasion should be accepted and perhaps even be exalted rather
Open Document