Dual Dreams

1761 Words8 Pages
Dual Dreams Amy Tan’s “Two Kinds” is a relatable American dream short story of a young girl who is trying to find herself. The protagonist, Jing-mei, is a strong-minded nine year old, who lives with her mother. She struggles with the high expectations of her mother, Mrs. Woo, to become a prodigy child. The story illustrates why immigrants battle for better opportunities for their children. The title itself gives the readers a hint about two different aspects that will be a part of the short story. Tan achieves the significance of the title “Two Kinds” through her use of three literary devices: conflict, point of view, and symbolism. To begin, Tan achieves the significance of the title “Two Kinds” by using conflict constantly throughout the…show more content…
Woo passes away. Jing-mei begins to transform into the daughter that her mother wants her to be, while still being able to be herself. For several years, Mrs. Woo has tried to enforce the importance of playing the piano in the short story to possibly help Jing-mei become a prodigy child. Jing-mei does not realize how much her mother cares for her until after her mother dies. The only reason Mrs. Woo gives her tough love is for her own benefit. Finally, she has grown up and notices that the only person stopping her from being somebody great was herself. Playing the piano was not as bad as she made it seem. Jing-Mei said, "I played a few bars, surprised at how easily the notes came back to me" (Tan 598). As a child, she played whichever song she felt like playing. She took advantage of her piano teacher’s, Mr. Chong, deafness and blindness. The fact that she was able to play the piano after so many years shows that she was slowly, but surely starting to find herself. If she honestly had no interest in the lessons she was taking, she would not be able to play a single note from the piano as an adult. The quote proves that Jing-mei was a very confused little girl. Does she really want to be herself, and not listen to her mother at all? Or does she want to be the person that her mother is pushing her to be? Either way without her mother's constant yelling, bickering, and love, Jing-mei may have never learned how to…show more content…
The very same piano that she despised, was the very same piano that helped mend the bond that Jing-mei has never had with her mother. Instead of Mrs. Woo arguing that Jing-mei made plenty of mistakes, she shows that she loves her daughter. Jing-Mei stated “I saw the offer as a sign of forgiveness, a tremendous burden removed” (Tan 597). After years of not knowing what her mother thought about the recital performance she did as a kid, she felt like a thousand pounds was lifted off her shoulders. From Jing-mei’s point of view, she is happy when her mother is happy. She could still be “Two Kinds” of daughters, and still make her mother proud of
Open Document