Janie's Pear Tree

1558 Words7 Pages
This part of the four chapters was my absolute favorite. It was filled with beautiful imagery that really displayed the comfort and tranquility that is found in the natural world. I find it so interesting that there is another tree metaphor that Hurston mentions, but I can tell that this specific pear tree will be one of the most powerful and prevalent symbols throughout the rest of the novel (I mean, there are three or so pages dedicated to it). Janie’s moment under this pear tree is more than just relaxing and leisure; it is the defining moment for her life. Janie’s epiphany on her expectations for her world transcend the monotony and depression that surrounds her, and it is seen in her heavily romanticized and sexualized standard on marriage,…show more content…
So far, she is this a very passive, quiet girl that is dictated by her Nanny and her environment, but yet she is surrounded by this powerful pear tree that symbolizes expression and freedom. Will she rise to the challenge, and when will she rise? Oh! Back to my point on the split narrative style (I was reminded when I talked about Janie’s passivity): this alternative between third-person omniscient and vernacular could possible represent Janie’s journey. Her quest that she will soon unfold will most likely be filled with numerous challenges, and – to me – she will conquer them by searching for her own voice. The journey to self-discovery is so complicated, so the back-and-forth narration is perhaps due to two reason: 1. Visibility. The colloquialism seems challenging to interpret at times, and without the Hurston’s own insight and voice in the third-person narration, her novel would lack so much brevity in terms of meanings and philosophies (imagine the pear tree being described with broken language) 2. The representation of how difficult it will be for Janie to find her voice: it will not be one linear path, it will be filled with uncertainties that require multiple resolutions (e.g. the two different styles) to fulfill her life’s goal or dreams and…show more content…
Then there is a depth of thought untouched by words, and deeper still a gulf of formless feelings untouched by thought. Janie waited a bloom time, and a green time and an orange time… She knew things that nobody had ever told her. For instance, the words of the trees and the wind… It was wonderful to see it take form with the sun and emerge from the gray dust of its making. Janie’s first dream was dead, so she became a woman” (24-25). The first block reminded me about the deceptive nature of human thought: how our thoughts seem to be initially correct by our immediate impulses, but, in reality, are so undeveloped by that “gulf” that leaves us unaware, unknowing, and scared. This natural tendency for individuals to wander within their own minds is clearly portrayed in Nanny’s death: a pang of regret, the “infinity of conscious pain” – “‘Lawd, you know mah heart. Ah done the best Ah could do. De rest is left to you’” (24). This sort of translates to Janie as well, who is still stuck in between her reality and her dreams. Her internal struggles are still present, a dilemma in which she sequesters all of her emotions and doubts inside of her, wondering which path to
Open Document