something you don’t find out how you feel until afterwards,’” (Pg. 50). The main dilemma in Tuck Everlasting is keeping the magical water of immortality a secret. The Tucks tried to keep the water a secret because, although it may not seem like it, immortality is a curse, not a blessing. If you want people to maintain their happy lives and not suffer the curse of immortality, then you should, like the Tucks, keep the water a secret because there is no point of life if you are immortal, it’s unnatural