Tuck Everlasting If you were Winnie Foster, from Tuck Everlasting by Natalie Babbitt, would you have drank the magical spring water? The magical spring water is a spring that contains water that give you immorality. If I were Winnie I would not have drank the water because life would be meaningless without an end. Also, you will be limited to the amount of things you can accomplish or do. Lastly, life would be very boring without an end. Life would be meaningless without an end. In the book