Explain Why The Armbands Should Not Be Banned From Schools

544 Words3 Pages
In The Tinker V. Des Moines Case, Justice Abe Fortas and Justice Hugo black states there reason why the armbands should or should not be banned from schools. Justice Abe Fortas believes the armbands should not be prohibited. To prove his case, he provides evidence from other cases. “Pugsley V. Sellmeyer, it does not concern aggressive disruptive action or even group demonstrations”. He is saying that wearing the armbands doesn’t harm nor hurt anyone in…show more content…
Justice Abe Fortas is stating that things like bring out the truthfulness in our society and how they feel about our freedom of speech. “Burnside V. Byars, materially and substantially interfere with the requirements appropriate discipline in the operation of the schools,” the prohibition cannot be sustained. He is saying that the school discipline towards the armbands are aren’t appropriate and cannot be carried out. In Meyer V. Nebraska Mr. McReynolds expressed this nation’s repudiation of the principle that a state might so conduct in schools as to “homogenous people.” I think this evidence is provided to show you how Mr. McReynolds feels about the schools punishment and banishment of the armbands. “A student’s right therefore, do not embrace merely the classroom hours.” “When he is in the cafeteria or, on the playing field , or on the campus during the authorized hours, he may express his opinion, even on controversial subjects.” Mr. Justice Abe Fortas explains that the first
Show More
Related

  • Black Armbands Should Be Banned

    430 Words  | 2 Pages

    Supreme Court made it to where students can show symbolic speech. However why would they have to do that? In 1968 there was a debate of whether or not black armbands that symbolized the soldiers in Vietnam who died, or it was for distraction. Among the people who described the entire thing there was Catherine Ross, Justice Hugo Black, and Cheif Justic Abe Fortas. There are those who believe that such symbols like armbands should be prohibited. They believe that symbolic things may show out and cause

    Read More

More about Explain Why The Armbands Should Not Be Banned From Schools

Open Document