Comparing The Tell-Tale Heart And The Black Cat

997 Words4 Pages
Egdar Allan Poe, is an American writer, who wrote, "The Tell-Tale Heart" and "The Black Cat". Both stories offer components of homicide and craziness; both have creepy and unnerving evening scenes. At first look, however, the protagonists of both stories appear to have next to no in like manner. On the off chance that the peruser looks all the more carefully, notwithstanding, the two men show up progressively similar: both share their criminal history in flashback, in this way unveiling their intentions and admitting to their wrongdoings. All the more significantly, as both characters describe their stories, they passionately shield their rational soundness. Due to these striking likenesses, it soon gets to be evident that the two men are significantly…show more content…
The storyteller lets us know that he had no objective explanation behind needing to murder the old man. In reality, he guarantees the old man had never treated him terribly and that he adored him and did not need his cash. Nonetheless, the old man had a "vulture eye - a pale blue eye, with a film over it" that unnerved the storyteller. The storyteller was alarmed of the "vulture eye" in light of the fact that in its outward grotesqueness, he "saw" his own appearance; the storyteller is internally revolting and appalling, for he arranged and executed homicide; his spirit is more frightful than the old man's eye. The peruser can then translate the "vulture eye" not as an organ of vision but rather as the homonym of "I." Thus, what the storyteller eventually needs to pulverize is the self, and he succumbed to this inclination when he could no more contain his staggering feeling of blame and surrendered himself to the law, uncovering the remaining parts of the old man covered underneath the floorboards. Presently, resolved to protect his rational soundness, he shares the unpleasant subtle elements of his wrongdoing. On the other hand, his silly apprehension of the "vulture eye," the lethal substance of his admission, and the self-ruinous conduct with which he surrendered himself undermine his dependability as a normal…show more content…
He, as well, recounts his story from a jail cell in the wake of submitting homicide. His casualty, be that as it may, was his wife. The storyteller lets us know that he and his wife were extremely cheerful, and together they cherished and claimed an assortment of pets. The storyteller can't completely disclose his move to pitilessness, be that as it may. From one viewpoint, he accuses his liquor abuse as a sane clarification for his emotional episodes. Then again, he blames an inalienable soul of unreasonableness that he says pressured him to reveal more than was prudent. Both, he says, drove him to manhandle his most loved pet, "a surprisingly vast and delightful [cat], completely dark, and shrewd to a bewildering degree." He cut the feline's eye from its attachment with his pen-blade following a night of lewdness. After the episode, the storyteller was perpetually helped to remember his pitilessness by the scarred grotesqueness of the harmed eye. To free himself from the ghoulish eye of his pet, he in the end executes the feline, hanging it from a tree in his greenery enclosure. Not long in the wake of pulverizing the creature, the storyteller brings home a second feline which "nearly resembled" his previous pet "in each admiration however one,this feline had a substantial, albeit uncertain splotch of white, covering about the entire locale of the bosom." Eventually,
Show More
Related

  • Comparing The Black Cat And The Tale-Tell Heart

    589 Words  | 3 Pages

    been and am,”(p. 81). The Author, Allan Poe, wrote gothic stories, titled The Black Cat and The Tale-Tell Heart which took place mainly at night. In the stories, the main character, the narrator wanted something but the removed, but the police came, or the house burnt and he got caught in both. You should never betray your creator in anyway. The conflict in Edgar Allen Poe’s stories The Black Cat and The Tale-Tell Heart show that you should never betray your creator. The narrator had something

    Read More

  • Essay Comparing The Tell Tale Heart And The Black Cat

    447 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Black Cat and The Tell Tale Heart are both short stories written by Edgar Allan Poe. These short stories are similar because they set the same theme, being the effects of a guilty conscience and the decent into madness. But in many ways, these stories are very different. In The Black Cat, the reader finds out what happens at the end of the story, while in The Tell Tale Heart, the narrator lets the reader know what will happen at the beginning of the story. The narrator’s anger in The Black Cat

    Read More

  • Essay Comparing The Tell Tale Heart And The Black Cat

    736 Words  | 3 Pages

    “The Tell-Tale Heart” and “The Black Cat” are stories written by Edgar Allan Poe, both sharing the topic of murder and mental insanity. Both stories share in romanticism and characterization .At the opening the protagonists in both stories do not have much in common: Through a close read, one can see that they actually have a lot of similarities; However criminal flashbacks and confessing their motives. Each story starts off with the criminal flashbacks. In “The Tell-Tale Heart” the protagonist

    Read More

  • Comparing The Black Cat And The Tell-Tale Heart By Edgar Allan Poe

    611 Words  | 3 Pages

    Throughout this paper, I will condense and analyze two pieces’ of Poe’s stories. First “The Black Cat” and following “The Tell-Tale Heart”. The conscience awareness of Poe’s characters is often questioned. This is seen in the narrators of “The Black Cat” and “The Tell-Tale Heart”. Although both pieces are unusual in their own ways, each one involves narrators with fatal ethics. Poe’s short story, “The Black Cat”, intwines horror, violence, and guilt throughout. The main character is mentioned as the

    Read More

  • Electric Castle Festival Case Study

    9656 Words  | 39 Pages

    How can Electric Castle Festival target international market in terms of marketing and event experience? Introduction The Electric Castle Festival is the biggest music festival in Romania so far(http://www.electriccastle.ro/en/dailylineup). It takes place in the North-Western part of the country, on the outskirts of Cluj city (in Bontida commune)where the ruins of the Banffy Castle are situated. Cluj is considered a metropole, the third biggest city in Romania with a population of 500,000(out of

    Read More

More about Comparing The Tell-Tale Heart And The Black Cat

Open Document