Henry David Thoreau's Argument

1230 Words5 Pages
Henry David Thoreau’s Walden is a book that is critical toward the way that people live their lives in the context of the circumstances of their life. Thoreau points out problems with the way people live their lives. One of those problems is a person’s propensity to live their life in a surplus to what is really essential. A person can be so caught up in the unnecessary matters of life that they simply do not have the ability to enjoy more important things. Therefore according to Thoreau, “finer fruits cannot be plucked”. (Economy) To a certain extent Thoreau’s issue can be justified as valid, but it’s also a mater that can be seen on a circumstantial basis. In today’s world there are people who allow themselves to be defined based on their…show more content…
According to Thoreau, elders should not be relied on and used for advice about life because for the most part their lives were basically failures and according to him would cause you to fail as well. His argument is invalid because of the past have relied on other people from earlier generations and have proved to be successful. In addition to this idea, just because a person is from the past doesn’t mean their ideas are wrong. A person can have wrong ideas if they’re young or old. Age does not always play a role in the validity of somebody’s…show more content…
What if it’s violated for something justifiable? Is it worth being recognized as laudable? These are all questions to points made by attorney James Humes of North Carolina during a speech being made to college students in 1968. Civil disobedience has always been a topic of discussion and has always had cases that spark popular controversy. Humes challenges the fact that society should not condone laws being violated, even for justifiable reasons and should especially not be praised. In writings such as Thoreau’s essay On the Duty of Civil Disobedience, Into the Wild, Antigone, and Martin Luther King, Jr.’s Letter from a Birmingham Jail, Humes argument is challenged and in most cases is gone
Open Document