an argument. He wants to show how today's France has been, perhaps uniquely, shambled by its history. He wants to emphasis how the sides that opposed each other in 1789 have never really gone away. Part of his thesis is that a predisposition to conflict and against compromise has made it harder for the French (than for the British) to create a suitable political and economic system for modern day society. Here I am less convinced that Moynahan has made his case. Yes, the shadow of the Bastille